Buying a new distributor. Need options

[xanatost]

Ok woke up this morning with a ton of stuff to do. Go to crank my hoe and no start. Thought it was my starter becuse it has been acting up for about a year. Replace it. Go to crank it still no go. I start checking wires. Not my first chevy and sure enough main battery line that is running to the starter is burnt up in one section. Replaced. Go to crank her up still no go! Now getting pissed! Start unplugging all the electric connections under the hood and spraying cleaner on them. Go to crank.... Still nothing, but she did turnover a hell of a lot better! Still pissed but not so much becuse she did turn over better. Now start checking all the spark plugs and wires. Nothing out of place or burnt. Check distributor and there it is! Dam distributor is broken where the cap screws down on top Ok few zip ties later running like a bat out of hell!!! No joke haven't ran this good as long as I can remember. Call parts store 150 for a new one! I want a after something better than stock. I have all ready up graded my coil and spark plug wires. What do y'all recommend? Not looking for a new system just something better than what's on her now.

I found this one: MSD

 

[SunlitComet]

thats the one i bought and it will be installed in a few weeks. my oem one is fine screw hole wise and they are excellent oem dizzy with one flaw. the vent screens an because clogged with debris and start damaging the inside of caps corrosion wise. i have burnt out 3 caps to misfiring in the last 14 months. all things over time wear as is my dizzy gear so a replacement is needed. i was going to put an oem back in there but since everything in my ignition system is msd besides the plugs, it just seemed fitting to to the dizzy too. and share the experience with others.

btw delphi has since redesigned ed the oem a while back.

---------- Post added at 08:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:43 AM ----------
sorry could net get the pictures on.


PATTERN FAILURES
Plagued with Problems by Design
O presence of a white or tan residue on the inner walls of
the cap and rotor, and the terminals will be encrusted
(see illustration 1). The contaminants are conductive and
can promote a misfire condition, resulting in misfire
codes being stored in the diagnostic memory.
Inspect the base of the distributor and the distributor
shaft for the presence of rust. While the distributor
housing is made of plastic, you are looking for an
accumulation of debris from other internal metal components.
Components that are affected by corrosion
should be replaced. The accumulation of debris in the
distributor housing can restrict the ventilation screens.
Most technicians are not aware that this style distributor
is fitted with vent screens, as the distributors on these
applications seldom have to be pulled for service, with
the exception of replacing the intake manifold gaskets.
The vents are positioned at the base of the distributor and
are almost impossible to see with the distributor mounted
in the engine (see illustration 2). In fact, the screens are
easily missed while viewing the distributor on a work
bench. The two vent screens are approximately the
diameter of a pencil eraser and they are easily plugged
when debris is present. The frequency in which they plug
increases with vehicle mileage. Naturally, as the engine
wears, the blow-by gases increase, thus an increase in
the gases collected in the distributor housing. A malfuncccasionally
you will encounter a system or component
that develops a history of pattern failures
that can elude your best efforts. Problems or premature
failures can result from a manufacturing defect with a
component, a problem due to the design of the system,
or a secondary system malfunction may lead to a premature
component failure. When the industry encounters
the same failures or circumstances, then most likely you
are dealing with a design issue. It is unlikely that multiple
manufacturers of the same part would make the same
manufacturing mistakes. Identifying and acknowledging
these issues early on are imperative in making an
accurate diagnosis in a timely manner, and in maintaining
good customer relations.
GM trucks and SUVs equipped with the Vortec engine
are good examples of an ignition system that has developed
some common failures that would be considered
a normal characteristic. Distributor cap and rotor contamination,
resulting in a misfire condition and stored
misfire codes, has become a common occurrence. The
codes may be cylinder-specific or random misfire codes.
It is not uncommon to remove the distributor cap on one
of these engines and observe heavy deposits of a white
or tan powdery residue. The distributor caps used on
these applications are susceptible to more than just
contamination problems. Read on for a thorough description
of some of the problems and possible solutions.
POOR DISTRIBUTOR VENTILATION
The aforementioned ignition system has encountered
excessive levels of distributor cap corrosion, resulting in
internal arcing and misfiring. Many technicians are of
the opinion that the type of metal used in the construction
of the terminals is the reason for the heavy concentrations
of deposits and misfire conditions. This is not the
case. GM has acknowledged what we have suspected all
along, that the corrosion condition and the heavy deposit
formation is the result of inadequate ventilation in
the distributor housing. The gases collect in the distributor
cap and housing, and in the presence of heat and high
voltage, form corrosive deposits, resulting in internal
arcing and misfire conditions. When these conditions
are present, the cap and rotor will usually reflect the presence of a white or tan residue on the inner walls of
the cap and rotor, and the terminals will be encrusted
(see illustration 1). The contaminants are conductive and
can promote a misfire condition, resulting in misfire
codes being stored in the diagnostic memory.
Inspect the base of the distributor and the distributor
shaft for the presence of rust. While the distributor
housing is made of plastic, you are looking for an
accumulation of debris from other internal metal components.
Components that are affected by corrosion
should be replaced. The accumulation of debris in the
distributor housing can restrict the ventilation screens.
Most technicians are not aware that this style distributor
is fitted with vent screens, as the distributors on these
applications seldom have to be pulled for service, with
the exception of replacing the intake manifold gaskets.
The vents are positioned at the base of the distributor and
are almost impossible to see with the distributor mounted
in the engine (see illustration 2). In fact, the screens are
easily missed while viewing the distributor on a work
bench. The two vent screens are approximately the
diameter of a pencil eraser and they are easily plugged
when debris is present. The frequency in which they plug
increases with vehicle mileage. Naturally, as the engine
wears, the blow-by gases increase, thus an increase in
the gases collected in the distributor housing. A malfuncccasionally
you will encounter a system or component
that develops a history of pattern failures
that can elude your best efforts. Problems or premature
failures can result from a manufacturing defect with a
component, a problem due to the design of the system,
or a secondary system malfunction may lead to a premature
component failure. When the industry encounters
the same failures or circumstances, then most likely you
are dealing with a design issue. It is unlikely that multiple
manufacturers of the same part would make the same
manufacturing mistakes. Identifying and acknowledging
these issues early on are imperative in making an
accurate diagnosis in a timely manner, and in maintaining
good customer relations.

 

[SunlitComet]

GM trucks and SUVs equipped with the Vortec engine
are good examples of an ignition system that has developed
some common failures that would be considered
a normal characteristic. Distributor cap and rotor contamination,
resulting in a misfire condition and stored
misfire codes, has become a common occurrence. The
codes may be cylinder-specific or random misfire codes.
It is not uncommon to remove the distributor cap on one
of these engines and observe heavy deposits of a white
or tan powdery residue. The distributor caps used on
these applications are susceptible to more than just
contamination problems. Read on for a thorough description
of some of the problems and possible solutions.
POOR DISTRIBUTOR VENTILATION
The aforementioned ignition system has encountered
excessive levels of distributor cap corrosion, resulting in
internal arcing and misfiring. Many technicians are of
the opinion that the type of metal used in the construction
of the terminals is the reason for the heavy concentrations
of deposits and misfire conditions. This is not the
case. GM has acknowledged what we have suspected all
along, that the corrosion condition and the heavy deposit
formation is the result of inadequate ventilation in
the distributor housing. The gases collect in the distributor
cap and housing, and in the presence of heat and high
voltage, form corrosive deposits, resulting in internal
arcing and misfire conditions. When these conditions
are present, the cap and rotor will usually reflect the
ILLUSTRATION 1:
LIGHT CORROSION DUE TO POOR VENTILATION
MIGHTY DISTRIBUTING SYSTEM OF AMERICA
tion in the PCV system can produce the same results. The
vent screens should be washed with a solvent, such as
brake clean, and any contamination expelled with air
pressure. Wear safety glasses to prevent an eye injury.
These conditions have prompted GM to release two
revised distributors that incorporate larger air-flow screens
for improved ventilation. GM recognizes 2001–2003
trucks and SUVs equipped
with 4.3L, 5.0L or 5.7L
engines as being the recipients
of the revised distributors.
Our research
shows that both distributors
(V-6 P/N 93441559
and V-8 P/N 93441558)
can retrofit applications
back to 1996. The list
prices of the distributors
from GM are $303.78 for
the V-6 and $447.75 for
the V-8. Considering the
cost of the replacement
distributor, many opt for a
clean-up of the existing
distributor.
MOISTURE ACCUMULATION
Convinced that moisture is collecting inside the cap and
promoting misfire conditions, some technicians seal the
distributor cap with silicone. Sealing the cap is not the
solution and may actually worsen the condition, especially
in cases where plugged vent screens are present,
preventing the escape of the gases. The moisture condition
may be influenced by the A/C system. On many
LARRY HAMMER
TECHNICAL SERVICES
applications, the A/C accumulator line is routed directly
over the distributor cap (see illustration 3). The condensation
from the line drips directly onto the distributor
cap and housing. If you identify this condition, installing
a foam sleeve over the accumulator line can minimize
the moisture problem. Water dripping on a hot distributor
cap can promote electrical tracking and arcing.
LOW PROFILE DESIGN
The low profile design of the distributor caps for these
applications is necessary, as the engine compartment
space for the distributor is limited. On most distributor
caps, the terminals are spaced a minimum of an inch
apart. With this style cap, some of the terminals come
within 1/8 inch of an adjacent terminal. The close
proximity of the terminals makes manufacturing of the
part a challenge. Any air or gas pockets in the plastic
molding process can eventually result in high voltage
arcing. The potential for arcing/flashover is great, while
leaving little evidence the condition has occurred. The
problems are further aggravated when high secondary
circuit resistance conditions are present. Current takes
the path of least resistance and often will arc to an
adjacent terminal, creating a misfire condition. For
example: Installing a new cap on a set of bad spark plug
wires can lead to a premature failure of the cap.
In summary: The design of this distributor makes for an
above-normal failure rate of caps and rotors. When
diagnosing a performance problem on this ignition
system, the cap and rotor should always be a first
suspect, regardless of how long it has been on the
engine. The high voltage terminals are molded into the
plastic housing in close proximity, which is a manufacturing
challenge. The manufacturer must consider terminal
position and molding issues such as air and gas
pockets in the plastic. The distributor has a history of
inadequate ventilation, which prompts an accumulation
of conductive deposits. When this occurs, the result
is misfiring, an illuminated SES lamp and stored trouble
codes. The cap is positioned directly beneath the A/C
accumulator line, which can drip water onto the distributor
cap.
Due to the design of the system, the distributor cap and
rotor are destined for failure.
ILLUSTRATION 2:
SCREENS ARE POSITIONED
AT DISTRIBUTOR BASE
ILLUSTRATION 3:
A/C ACCUMULATION LINE DRIPS WATER ONTO CAP

 

[xanatost]

Thanks sun. Ill be ordering on Wednesday.