I cant speak for all of them, but i noticed when i first got my yukon, it had one that made alot of noise, so i replaced it, didnt have alot of cash at the moment so i bought the cheapest one they had and it seemed to be louder than the other after a few days. When i finally bought a good high quality replacement the noise was gone. So i dont know if its just the different construction of the parts but just my experience.