Should this pre-purchase inspection be a dealbreaker?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

the 18th letter

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Posts
750
Reaction score
695
Location
Northern New Jersey
Just ask. That's what i do if they tell me no, i can't take it to another chevy or whatever dealer they're shady as hell
I have a trusted mechanic who I wanted to use when I was looking and two places that had trucks I was interested in were willing to let him look at it on the lot but both wanted a “refundable” deposit to take it elsewhere. I didn’t wind up getting either one.
 

K2 Kaiju

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2015
Posts
699
Reaction score
741
Location
The Depths
Curious to see what he did. I will tell you that Carfax is not to be trusted. Wife traded in her car last week. It was a Lexus 1 owner we got with 18K miles in 2021. Its listed now as a 1 owner vehicle with 36k miles. Our 2nd ownership is nowhere to be found; instead it states "lease was purchased by owner" - absolutely fraud IMO. If you see a 'one owner' that has 2 distinct locations, be wary...
 

91RS

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2009
Posts
2,587
Reaction score
2,033
Location
GA
It’s not fraud. Carfax can only show what is reported to them and that’s clearly stated on their web site. They can’t and don’t know everything that has happened to every car ever and sometimes mistakes are made in the reporting. I’ve seen carfax show multiple owners when the title number was the same because a change was made to the title. I’ve seen mileage discrepancies because the oil change place typed in the customer’s phone number in the mileage box. You have to use the information provided by Carfax as one piece of the puzzle and interpret the information to make a decision. No Carfax report overrules getting a proper PPI by a qualified tech that knows the vehicle. There are still plenty of jurisdictions that do not report accidents to Carfax and most body shops do not report to Carfax.
 

petethepug

Michael
Joined
May 4, 2016
Posts
2,958
Reaction score
3,192
Location
SoCal
I’ve had two experiences w/ CarMax. One for a job, the other for an 06 YXL Denali.

First, The job. Well, laughable. As I progressed through the interviews the mgmt was more underhanded, disrespectful and condescending.

They actually were upset when I pointed out that incentives (commission) structures were able to be exploited by mgmt if you didn’t do your 6 day a week open to close shifts and even that wasn’t a guarantee.

The purchase, 2nd. I walked into a lot void of employee. I found my reserved car embedded so at least 4 cars would have to be moved to drive it. The truck was unlocked and the keys were inside.

The outside was a 7/8. The inside was a hard 5 and the drive train was a hard 7. They insisted they pull a credit. They offered 4%. I said ok just to move along. My credit union had me @ 2.9%. The rack was bent, steering wheel @ 3 o’clock and pulled hard to the left. Traffic behind me honked because it’s back end tracked in the other lanes Lolololo!

They closed on the truck with “sign here”. The APR jumped to 6% with our prices are non negotiable. It’s better (for us) that way. Less hassle. They said they’d fix the truck after I bought it. Lolololo

Just for fun I said ok, put all that in a due bill please. That really pissed them off. They said I was lucky they were even financing me Lolololo!!! They’re a horrible company that is run by a huge automotive conglomerate that perfected exploiting wages from employees and profit from customers with a board of directors each banking millions. Just Run from that place.
 

blackelky

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2023
Posts
582
Reaction score
763
I’ve had two experiences w/ CarMax. One for a job, the other for an 06 YXL Denali.

First, The job. Well, laughable. As I progressed through the interviews the mgmt was more underhanded, disrespectful and condescending.

They actually were upset when I pointed out that incentives (commission) structures were able to be exploited by mgmt if you didn’t do your 6 day a week open to close shifts and even that wasn’t a guarantee.

The purchase, 2nd. I walked into a lot void of employee. I found my reserved car embedded so at least 4 cars would have to be moved to drive it. The truck was unlocked and the keys were inside.

The outside was a 7/8. The inside was a hard 5 and the drive train was a hard 7. They insisted they pull a credit. They offered 4%. I said ok just to move along. My credit union had me @ 2.9%. The rack was bent, steering wheel @ 3 o’clock and pulled hard to the left. Traffic behind me honked because it’s back end tracked in the other lanes Lolololo!

They closed on the truck with “sign here”. The APR jumped to 6% with our prices are non negotiable. It’s better (for us) that way. Less hassle. They said they’d fix the truck after I bought it. Lolololo

Just for fun I said ok, put all that in a due bill please. That really pissed them off. They said I was lucky they were even financing me Lolololo!!! They’re a horrible company that is run by a huge automotive conglomerate that perfected exploiting wages from employees and profit from customers with a board of directors each banking millions. Just Run from that place.
I've always loathed carmax. Always steer people aways from them. Autolenders has a similar model but not too bad they said they don't negotiate but they do.
 

Wwes

Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2016
Posts
60
Reaction score
50
I've sold 3 cars to Carmax and bought 1. The cars I sold they offered slightly above KBB trade-in value (and one time - in 2021 - way over), and all three times I walked away with a check and a smile.

The one I bought was a great deal, they did agree to replace two front tires and fix a bumper scratch as a condition of sale. The finance APR was in line with market rates, and the purchased extended warranty from them was a great buy and we got the money out of that.

I know that whomever eventually bought the three cars I sold them ended up with solid unwrecked and unmolested cars.
 

91RS

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2009
Posts
2,587
Reaction score
2,033
Location
GA
Statistically, they can’t all be bad, but I wouldn’t buy a car at Carmax either. Pretty much everything I’ve seen there that I might have been interested in is overpriced and I’ve seen so many cars from there was were polished turds.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
132,026
Posts
1,861,216
Members
96,472
Latest member
lpadron1
Top