ya, I updated with a video above showing how to bench test, either way when you tilted it forward and the gear slid up that is why one of the noises is happening even though it may stay back from it most of the time vibration alone will make it move and smack on the flex plateHonestly I wants sure how the starter should act off the car hahaha. So the gear should only deploy when the solenoid pushes out to connect with flywheel. Thank you so much. Let me shop a starter.