Actually when you order the direct bolt you don't have a choice you get the whole assembly I pictured above. And of course it is the smart thing to do.
Post some pics of the cats. Would like to see how bad they are. I am guessing there are burned shut from running a rich mixture down them.
---------- Post added at 08:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:29 PM ----------
Also I would still recommend some one with the same engine chime in here. I could be wrong, but a open hole in the throttle plate just does not sound right and maybe along with old o2 sensors maybe be causing this mess for you I mean the TB, WOW.
It is like someone drilled a hole to get the engine to run faster for a high electric load or something.