Weathertech vs Husky Weatherbeater

[sealandsky]

After 5 years of the same Weathertech mats, the front set started looking scruffy and had some "curl". The second row and rear cargo still look good. So I ordered a replacement set of the 3D front mats for the front and they arrived yesterday. They look great! The fit is better than the first gen mats and the portion extending over the door sill plate extends further to help keep the mess off the floor. Long term test begins...

 

[Prospect62]

Just installed some Husky 18231 Weatherbeater mats. The fit is superb and they are a nice mix of sturdy and supple in construction. They cover every necessary area and look great. Highly recommended.

 

[WillCO]

Just installed some Husky 18231 Weatherbeater mats. The fit is superb and they are a nice mix of sturdy and supple in construction. They cover every necessary area and look great. Highly recommended.

Mine must have been made on a Friday afternoon or something. There's enough space exposed beneath the 2nd row cover around the transmission hump to slide an Altoids box in.

And after 3+ years, these curls around the edges have never laid down.

 

[Prospect62]

Huh. Mine look nothing like that.

 

[Tahoe14]

Lifetime warranty give them a call.

 

[WillCO]

Lifetime warranty give them a call.

Did all that at the beginning. They were initially very responsive and sent me a replacement second row mat. It had all the same issues the first one had. I further engaged, and the Husky rep stopped responding.

I've pointed out above in this thread, and will again here for posterity - the Husky rep admitted at the time (which was September 2016) that they did not have access to an actual 2016 Tahoe/Yukon and instead relied on measurements provided them by GM. That would explain the gaps, though not the curling plastic. Perhaps by now they have been able to measure an actual vehicle.

I guess my experience with Husky liners must be different than everyone else's.

 

[olyelr]

Did all that at the beginning. They were initially very responsive and sent me a replacement second row mat. It had all the same issues the first one had. I further engaged, and the Husky rep stopped responding.

I've pointed out above in this thread, and will again here for posterity - the Husky rep admitted at the time (which was September 2016) that they did not have access to an actual 2016 Tahoe/Yukon and instead relied on measurements provided them by GM. That would explain the gaps, though not the curling plastic. Perhaps by now they have been able to measure an actual vehicle.

I guess my experience with Husky liners must be different than
everyone else's.

same as mine

 

[MechEng813]

Weathertech for my Yukon, and Husky for the wife's Acadia. Can't even tell the difference.