I've had mixed luck with both, but where I live now there's a great indy shop right around the corner that does exceptional work, as evidenced by their Google reviews. They did fabulous work on our G35X, and the local GMC dealer did a crappy job on my 2012 XL Denali, and their Google reviews predicted that would be my experience there, and it was. My advice is to rely on the Google reviews to find the best shop near you, and go there.I trust the opinions in the NNBS group more than the K2XX and T1XX group LOL...
For body work and repainting, which way do you guys lean if the pricing is similar - dealership or independent shop? I'm most concerned with paint quality and matching (metallic), I can't see how there would be much of a difference in mechanically putting things back together. Would you view the dealership in higher regard as OEM-like or no?