You're 2010 model should have the deflector shield installed as OEM. Here's the neighbors that we did the AFM delete on last weekend:
Melling oil pumps come with each possible o-ring, and they give a pretty good explainer. If the end of your pickup tube does not get wider slightly where it goes into the pump, but it's the exact same diameter all the way to the end..... Then it's the black o-ring. If it widens out a little bit, then it's the red o-ring. I using micrometer to verify, but if you look carefully you can tell the difference with your eyes. Below picture is his red o-ring, if I remember correctly he was at about 192,000 miles. He was getting between 15 and 20 psi oil pressure. I'll throw in the picture where it shows the old one next to an oem Mahle that we were using to replace it:


Not only did the old o-ring look flat on both the inside and outside, it apparently shrank a bit. Pick up tube literally fell out of the pump once unbolted.
Get yourself one of the pickup tube girdles so you can use two bolts to hold the pickup tube to the pump. Inexpensive piece of mind.
