Weighing in here - Optima Red Top seem to be garbage now based on my experience. My first RedTop (got in maybe 2004?) was great - ran for 7 years. Have had terrible luck with 3-4 of them since. One went about 2.5 years and crapped out, so it was replaced by AAP under warranty. The replacement went 1.5 years and died, and they wouldn't replace it because the warranty term (3 years) had expired -- it was tied back to the original battery purchase. I gave it one more shot and put one in my 2003 Yukon and now this one has died after only 9 months. So, between my 2000 Yukon, 2003 Yukon and 2012 Tahoe, I've had a lot of issues with them.
I'm trying to figure out what to get now. Do you think AGM is better than wet lead acid? This is for my 2003 Yukon. I'm inclined to go BCI/lead acid/wet now instead of AGM, unless someone can talk me out of it. Thinking I'll get a Napa Legend Premium for 169.99. They are supposedly made by Deka/East Penn Manufacturing.
Any thoughts on what I should go with?