For noise - quieter. They only run when they need.
Performance - more. No parasitic draw.
Cooling - yes. Our rigs have had efans since 2005.
If your cooling system is failing you, you need to determine how and why. I still want to know how you're measuring temperature. The gauge on the dash has a pretty wide 'dead zone' and will stay in the middle from ~180-220 degrees. So if that's your guidance, I'd suggest using a scan tool to check coolant temps and validate the nature of your problem.
Regarding overheating present unless you raise engine RPM:
- Check coolant level and condition. Start the car, take the cap off your coolant tank, grab a multi meter and set to DCV. Dunk one end in the coolant, the other to ground. If you get 0.3v or more, than your coolant is shot.
- Any buildup in the reservoir? If it's there, it's elsewhere too.
- How's that thermostat? Aftermarket ones have a smaller valve by about 30%. OEM ONLY.
- Heater cores plugged up? If they are, you'll overheat because of how these systems are plumbed.
- How's that fan clutch doing? They wear out. When they fail, the fan won't spin fast enough to move the air needed to cool your engine.
- If your coolant is nasty, among other things like clogging up the radiator / heater cores, you can also ***** your water pump. The impeller is metal. It too is subject to corrosion