Its not BS it's physics lol. Weight needs more energy to move. It's really that simple.
Rotational mass is a huge deal. Its one of the most 'felt' things there is. Why do you think sports car have such light wheels?
It absolutely does make a difference. Still it's hard to diagnose from the internet. If the brakes are dragging they will get hot. Piping hot if it's dragging as much as he says they are. You could feel the heat with your hand or a infared thermometer.
Be interesting to see what it actually ends up being.
yes it will, but it won't be the brakes
I bet it's the big pedal, my wife can jump in mine and be getting 2-3 mpg more than me and it's not the weight, it's the way she drives versus how I drive
I bet the dealer won't find any issue either if the OP even bothers to ever follow up
these aren't F! car's with carbon fiber parts, they can tow and haul thousands of pounds and the mpg is directly affected by how you drive in fact it's the biggest factor more than anything else. I can make my 12 get 7.5 or 14 on purpose and I can make my 18 silverado get 7.5 or 25 (it's much more efficient when coaxed, my best on it is 32mpg).
if I am wrong so be it, but the wheels spun free according to the dealer and nobody else has reported having lost mpg from a brake upgrade.