The oil pressure sensor screen can get clogged up with junk, and provide false readings. Mine did that.
I saw a watched a video that said to replace the sensor while doing an oil change to save time (two birds/one stone). Remove the oil filter, drain oil before doing the sensor and screen so that you can blow air down the hole that the sensor threads into, so the built up gunk gets forced down and out of the oil filter housing. (I guess it's a straight shot down through the block from the pressure sensor to the oil filter.)
Just changing the sensor, or sensor & screen won't remove whatever gunk is present, and throw off the sensor. Even if your cold PSI to hot PSI sweep is the same as always, the gauge will present some wonky readings.
Here's the video: