PMI is worth the money, IF
1) You get more money (dividends/cashflow) in the stock market than you would get with just paying less without having PMI
2) If you invest the money that you save on the down payment and leverage it...meaning you invest it in the stock market e.g. where you historically get 8-10% per year. It will nicely compound while you pay artificially low interest rates for your mortgage and inflation is eating the debt over time.
People often don't consider that as they don't understand how wealth building works. As long as you are good with money and don't live beyond your means that's the ideal way to get rich with other people's money. In this case from the bank
Yeah, but there is this thing called taxes that people also do not generally consider lol. Taxes are your enemy when investing. You want to avoid them when you can. You don’t want to incur them to meet expenditures, especially when you’re young.
If you’re selling from your portfolio every year to meet capital payments, you’re probably generating some level short term cap gains. Based on your income level, those are costly. Certainly not ideal to generate. It chips away at your overall appreciation, which is always the goal.
Unless you income stream is entirely tax free in state specific munis. At that point, what are you investing a few hundred grand in a SMA where you own the bonds individually and then kick the income in an account to earn a few thousand a year in income payments?
But by your - “Historically you get 8-10 percent a year” analogy….that’s if you’re invested purely in the Sp500….But doing so means you’re not really generating income. SP 500 dividend yield is barely over 1%. So when you add in Higher income producing assets, you now tend to lower those returns because your portfolio isn’t entirely US large cap equities. Or you invest in high yield / junk bonds, which they won’t tend to default…but will add volatility to your overall return .
Also you have to note That is also an annualized return over a very long time span. So some years (possibly consecutive too) you can be down 10% or more. That’s not when you want to sell. You want to add.
I do investing for a living. Wealthy people never sell from their investment portfolios to get access to money. They borrow against it for a really. Low rate. They avoid taxes doing it that way too. They certainly don’t pay PMI. In fact, if anything they'd rather have 20% down because their LTV is lower and they can take out a larger HELOC to invest if their property value has gone up.
Older people use investment income to pay for expenses. Older people also don’t tend to buy homes and expensive items like cars.