So keep using premium? Seems to last longer. But I didn’t notice the shuttering happening more until after I started using premium. Which makes me want to use e85 again
If you're okay with the price of premium, then you're prime for E85. Roughly calculating, E85 will use 25-30% more fuel than non-ethanol fuel, so your MPG will suffer 25%-30%. If the price of E85 is 25%-30% cheaper than premium, then you're breaking even or coming out ahead. Talk about a life hack!
The thing is, the fuel labeled "E85" are often not actually 85% ethanol. In some places, it is. In my parts, it averages 60%. So, I wouldn't need the price of E85 to be quite that ~30% lower than premium to break even. Maybe only 25% less to throw out a figure. Even if you don't break even or better, it's okay cuz the fact that it's cleaning your fuel system and combustion chambers has value. So, enjoy the cheap gas and ignore the MPG.
If you have easy access to E85, run it for a few tankfuls and see if there's any difference. When your tank gets down to around 1/4 or so, dump a can of Berryman's B12 in it and drive it down to 1/8ish and refuel. Do this as often as you want.
If you wanna know the actual ethanol content of the ethanol fuel you're getting, you can test it with something like this:
https://fuel-it.com/products/ethanol-content-tester-1
I use this one (their older version) almost every tankful to test my actual alcohol content to compare to what the alcohol sensor I recently installed on my Tahoe is reporting.