I think the Burb. Private Party one owner, new tires and all maintenance records, at least you should be able to figure out what you are getting, not sure if you can with the ones from the dealerships.
The black one seems ok as well. The lifted first one strikes me as odd, why would you not post the miles unless they are pretty high and the camo stripes as well as all other equipment mounted on the thing indicate that it must have been off road/hunting quite a bit.
My vote goes to the Burb, negotiate the price down a bit and with a little TLC, I think you will havbe a great truck.
(Of course in all cases, the decison needs to be made AFTER the vehicle has been inspected IN PERSON, ........... I have been mislead too many times by pictures/descriptions advertised by the seller).
Good Luck, keep us posted.