XT5 Opinions? Thinking of purchasing a 2017

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

t_bergman

Full Access Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Posts
151
Reaction score
236
Location
Chicago
Looking for any opinions on the XT5, specifically 2017-2019; in short, wanting something that I can run around in, is comfortable, and that can hold 2 adults, kids and luggage.

As many know, I have a 2013 Yukon 2500 that I'm not super keen to be driving to the store, work, the train, etc. It excels and will continue to be the road trip vehicle to the lake, road trip etc.

I've read about the thermostat issues and general dislike (not sure why) of the 8 speed transmission; and seeing if I might have missed anything else that I should be paying attention to.

Looking to keep this under $20k, the dealer (Cadillac) which service's my 2013 Yukon 2500 has a 2017 XT5 Platinum AWD for $19k which is expensive and I need them to get it down to $17k for us to have a deal but heading to look at the car sometime over the next few days.
 

Tahoe14

Full Access Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2014
Posts
1,998
Reaction score
1,248
Location
Central Fl
The longer they have it on their lot the easier it will be to negotiate pricing, a lot of times they will reduce the price every 15-30 days. Look at the vehicle on their website and see if they use carfax, look at the carfax report and it will tell you how long they have had the vehicle. Good luck.
 

petethepug

Michael
Joined
May 4, 2016
Posts
3,197
Reaction score
3,528
Location
SoCal
That’s a nice trim level. Suede covered dash and headliner, heated & vented front seats, led headlamps, heads up display and pano sunroof. Once you get used to the vented front seats you’ll be glad to know BTdieselworks has a kit to add the option to the 2500.

17 is a good year as it just had $10k+ depreciation fall off in past 2 years. Platinum holds value better. Try and get coverage for sunroof breakage or have comprehensive coverage on insurance policy for non traffic damage on sunroof.

Hey @t_bergman , this was Oct 2024, did ya get it?
 
OP
OP
T

t_bergman

Full Access Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Posts
151
Reaction score
236
Location
Chicago
@petethepug Finally found a good one! Picked it up on Tuesday and got it back from the Cadillac Dealer yesterday.


A couple of thoughts from my search and how I'm liking the XT5:

-Dealers are not very keen on making a cash deal; certain dealers also have the mindset of "I know what I've got" and then the car is still sitting on the lot weeks after I've put an offer in which I believe was fair. I recorded the VIN and kept track of the selling dealers via CarFax; I know of four XT5 which are still for sale but dealers wouldn't budge on the price.

-I was offered protection plans ranging from $6k-12k even when the car was still under it's bumper to bumper warranty. That's where they wanted to make up some of their losses; they bought the car for $28,500 on trade.

-I took advantage of some very bad weather in Chicago and headed out to purchase the XT5 I finally bought; car was clean on the bottom and near perfect for a used interior with the exception that the tire tread was gone. It was the first car the Genesis dealer has sold that day, they sold another after I had wrapped up but it was slow and they were at least eager to get it off their lot after 9 weeks. It's under factory warranty until March and I've already had it into a dealer I use for my 2500 with which was willing to go through the car and find items that we're in need of fixes.

-I was able to negotiate the price with it being my responsibility to put new tires on the car; KBB with the options said the car was $31,006 ($29,624-32,387), it's an AWD Prem. Lux with the 3.6L V6 with built in nav which comes with the upgraded Bose speakers which MSRP was $55,140. Dealer had it listed for $28,420 and after a bit of back and forth landed on $26,000 + tax, title, and doc fees for OOD price. With new tires, alignment (at a shop I trusted, not the dealer which just took a loss) and a few items taken care of under the bumper to bumper I'm in the car for $27,700 (50.2% of MSRP) which is under the depreciation curve by approximately 18 months.

-I posted the above numbers to show it's possible to still work a deal but you've got to have time on your side and be ready to walk away from the car which doesn't make sense. I was only looking for a car which I could get under the depreciation curve as it's not the Yukon's or Tahoe's which we all love and have a deeper connection to.

-I've tested 8 XT5's in the past three months, the trim level scheme changed in 2020 and options became more a la carte so if you have a specific item you're looking for it's going to be trim 2017-2019 and then could be in any vehicle in 2020+.

-I like the 9 speed (2020+) over the 8 speed (2017-2019) and the 2.0L felt underwhelming when I test drove a 2020.

-There is a difference in the CUE system from 2019 to the 2020 gen however it wasn't that big of a deal when not able to sit in the cars side by side. The wireless phone charger needs to be replaced in a 2017 if that's important to you.

-I put defender2's on the XT5, their a bit beefier than what came off the factory line but I can't tell a difference. The XT5 rides like a cloud compared to my 2500.

-Why did I choose the XT5 over a GM, Chevy or other product? I wanted something which I didn't need to search far and wide for the v6, AWD, and have nicer materials than the terrain or the equinox. The last Terrain with a v6 was a 2017 and didn't have CarPlay included (this is a big deal for my wife), and was very hard to find a nice example in the Denali trim. Same with the Equinox dropping the v6 in 2017 and impossible to find anything which hadn't been just beaten up.

-I've had it out in the snow already and the AWD system works great, cabin noise is minimal and is just really nice to be able to run around without putting 3-5 miles per trim on the 2500.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
133,008
Posts
1,878,348
Members
97,951
Latest member
13yukondenalipsl

Latest posts

Top