Engine Oil Overfill

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

OP
OP
E

Eddie_Tahoe

TYF Newbie
Joined
Oct 17, 2022
Posts
7
Reaction score
19
I appreciate all the great advice folks! Manual says 5qt. Reading slightly lower on back side of dipstick (about at O instead of R in "OPERATING RANGE"). Dipstick wasn't perfectly horizontal when I took pic. Reading probably a little high. It's a good 1/2-3/4" past top hole in any case. Street its parked on not perfectly level but not that far off.

Dipstick smells like oil to me with no obvious fuel odor.

Shop's half hour away and driving back sounds risky. Tried to crack drain plug to let a little out but way too tight. Afraid I'll break ratchet, plug, or shoulder if I keep at it. Setup here no good for wrenching anyway. Ordered a big syringe so I can try pulling some out from dipstick tube. Guess I'm not driving anywhere for a few days.

Thanks again. Seem like easy fix. I just hope no damage is done. Do the pressure readings sound weird?
 

15burban

Full Access Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2023
Posts
200
Reaction score
362
Location
Wisconsin
What were your pressure readings before the oil change? Every vehicle can be a little different. Even different oil filters or a defective bypass valve can give different readings.

If I were in your shoes I would call the place, tell them the situation, send them the picture if you want or they ask for it, and tell them you are driving it there or towing it at their expense. If driving it if something happens to the motor on the way there it's on their dime. After they fix their mistake don't go back there.
 

OR VietVet

GMT800 SUV/Trucks
Supporting Member
Military
Joined
Oct 8, 2014
Posts
21,592
Reaction score
39,119
Location
Willamette Valley
So you were using a ratchet and socket and could not break the drain plug loose. That is straight up bull*s*h*i*t. Drain plug too tight and I bet the filter is too and overfilled. They would pay me double my money back because of the drive there and to get me out of there. Incompetence for an oil change is terrible.

I had a customer tell me one day that oil changes are easy. I said, "You are right, if they are done correctly".
 

PPV_2018

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2024
Posts
218
Reaction score
387
Location
U.S.A.
So you were using a ratchet and socket and could not break the drain plug loose. That is straight up bull*s*h*i*t. Drain plug too tight and I bet the filter is too and overfilled. They would pay me double my money back because of the drive there and to get me out of there.

wow what’s crazy is i was going to say the exact same thing!

I usually dread the first oil change on any new to me vehicle because I’m already knowing the p.o. Probably had the changes done at a shop where they used an impact at max setting to put the plug on .

With the Ppv, it was not the drain plug but the damn filter that crumpled like a wet cookie because it was installed so tight … :( like come on , seriously
 

Eman85

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2021
Posts
492
Reaction score
740
Put the truck on level ground and let it sit allowing the oil to drain back to the pan if it's been run. Wipe the stick clean and take a reading. Look carefully at both sides of the stick. Many times the stick will rub the tube and smear oil making it read wrong.
 
OP
OP
E

Eddie_Tahoe

TYF Newbie
Joined
Oct 17, 2022
Posts
7
Reaction score
19
What were your pressure readings before the oil change? Every vehicle can be a little different. Even different oil filters or a defective bypass valve can give different readings.

If I were in your shoes I would call the place, tell them the situation, send them the picture if you want or they ask for it, and tell them you are driving it there or towing it at their expense. If driving it if something happens to the motor on the way there it's on their dime. After they fix their mistake don't go back there.

Honestly never paid much attention to pressure readings before. I know they were always in range. Otherwise I'd have noticed. Best I can recall maybe 20-25psi (about 10 or 11 o'clock) was normal. Can't remember if it went higher while warming up or not.

In principle I know y'all are right but also inclined to cut losses. Like I'm supposed to trust this shop to make it right? Might well just make it worse. If motor seizes on the way there I can yell all I want but what can I really do, sue them? If I can pull some oil out the top at least I can trust myself to get the level right and hope for the best.

Saddest part is this is the 6th supposedly reputable shop I've tried in the area and the rest were no better. Until now this one seemed like the best.

Grateful for your advice.
 

homesick

The Best Me I Can Be
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Posts
1,708
Reaction score
4,520
Honestly never paid much attention to pressure readings before. I know they were always in range. Otherwise I'd have noticed. Best I can recall maybe 20-25psi (about 10 or 11 o'clock) was normal. Can't remember if it went higher while warming up or not.

In principle I know y'all are right but also inclined to cut losses. Like I'm supposed to trust this shop to make it right? Might well just make it worse. If motor seizes on the way there I can yell all I want but what can I really do, sue them? If I can pull some oil out the top at least I can trust myself to get the level right and hope for the best.

Saddest part is this is the 6th supposedly reputable shop I've tried in the area and the rest were no better. Until now this one seemed like the best.

Grateful for your advice.

LOL, detailing shops are no better when you're tall enough to see that they often skip the roof. I've had 3 places, so far, do that; plus another that did ceramic on my truck.

joe
 
Last edited:

Jimmyy

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2020
Posts
589
Reaction score
1,283
Location
Minnesota
I had a DD with the 3800, the dealer put 2x the amount of oil in it. I'm guessing 4-5 qts before lunch and 4-5 after lunch. I put close to 1k miles on it before I checked the oil. It just sounded different at Idle. I drove back to the dealer asap once I checked it. The service writer told we're too busy for an oil change. I told you better check my oil level before you send me away. It was the 3rd time he checked it that he looked at me and I said yeah its over filled. So they removed all the extra oil plus another 1/2qt. Lol But the car had no side effects. That when I learned for the umpteenth time always check their work. I had the airbox not put back together 2 times at different shops, the oil cap not put back on a few. 1 time at a quick oil change place I had jump out in the shop a d tell them to shut the engine off as all the oil was coming out of the fliter. No sure if it was loose or not even installed.
 
Last edited:

Miami-Dade

Staff member
Super Moderator
Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2016
Posts
3,954
Reaction score
5,039
Saddest part is this is the 6th supposedly reputable shop I've tried in the area and the rest were no better. Until now this one seemed like the best.

Grateful for your advice.
I would try to find a good independent shop and bring your own oil and filter. That is what i do. They charge 20 bucks to change it.

If i am out of town I go the the Chevrolet dealer.
 
Top