Reading my shop manual on the subject, it says 50-60psi, so if you are getting 43.5 that definitely is a problem and would call out a pump replacement.
If you happen to be using the Tech 2, could you take note of which menu and section you are at when you are reading the fuel pressure and post it back up? I looked and looked and couldn't find it anywhere. I suspect the 2007 model year doesn't communicate between the PCM and any fuel pressure sensor (maybe an internal sensor in the pump itself that the pump uses) as when I did the "all sensor" read on my dongle scanner, it lists 155 different sensor values, but fuel pressure isn't one of them. The shop manual calls out using a manual gauge on the fuel rail to test pressure, so again, I think the 2007 model year didn't get that ability, which is actually quite surprising giving how important fuel pressure is in an EFI engine.
Anyway, anxious to hear the results of the pump swap. I will check my pressure at the rail with a gauge here in the next day or so and will report the results.