Head gasket replacement checklist

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

swathdiver

Full Access Member
Joined
May 18, 2017
Posts
19,582
Reaction score
26,265
Location
Treasure Coast, Florida
Yes but what could the difference be? The only thing I can think of is the addition of AFM/DOD in 2009 and above engine. They should both fit. The later valve cover is half the price! I am tempted to buy both from the dealer and compare.

I think the difference lies in the size of the hose fitting coming out of the valve cover.
 
OP
OP
Matahoe

Matahoe

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2016
Posts
445
Reaction score
164
Location
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Got done cleaning all the valves and rebuilding the lifters. The washed out area on the passenger head that looked suspicious seems to be a crack. I used a two part red penetrant and developer. I had to edit/highlight the crack because I sprayed too much developer and it covered it up.

This is all preliminary checking and I still want to pressure wash the head today and redo the developer test. Still wondering if it is worth having a machine shop do their own tests regardless of what i find? At this point I am tempted to just slap on a head gasket, button everything back up and live with it. Although re-torquing the head may result in elongating the crack.

Really looking for ideas here. A new GM cylinder head is $400. thanks.

20180716_055937.jpg View attachment 203536 20180713_012913.jpg
 
Last edited:

Tonyrodz

Resident Resident
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Posts
31,469
Reaction score
46,641
Location
Central Jersey
Got done cleaning all the valves and rebuilding the lifters. The washed out area on the passenger head that looked suspicious seems to be a crack. I used a two part red penetrant and developer. I had to edit/highlight the crack because I sprayed too much developer and it covered it up.

This is all preliminary checking and I still want to pressure wash the head today and redo the developer test. Still wondering if it is worth having a machine shop do their own tests regardless of what i find? At this point I am tempted to just slap on a head gasket, button everything back up and live with it. Although re-torquing the head may result in elongating the crack.

Really looking for ideas here. A new GM cylinder head is $400. thanks.

View attachment 203535 View attachment 203536 View attachment 203537
I'd look for another head, or even a set. They're plentiful in the yards, unless this is your dd. Or even repair the crack.
 

randeez

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2017
Posts
7,430
Reaction score
23,618
Location
south florida
what did you find when you lifted the heads? head gasket obviously failed?
the updated valve covers just come with an internal baffle to help slung oil stay out of the pcv tube, not sure of outlet size but shouldnt be hard to adapt.
heads??? id say bring it to the machine shop and let them decide, they look at heads all day and would probably have a better idea of what may be acceptable and could prob tell you before doing any thing to it (spending money on it). machine shop may also have a head laying around, check craigslist...i wouldnt buy a new one from gm.

Unless your 110% sure headgasket was your issue, I wouldn't reuse the head, would suck to put it all back together just to have same symptoms all the gaskets, tty bolts, fluids youd have to buy again would have bought a new head
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
Matahoe

Matahoe

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2016
Posts
445
Reaction score
164
Location
Grand Rapids, Michigan
The local engine shop said they will pressure test it for leaks. The charge would only be $25 if they find a leak. $150 if it's found to be ok. They would then continue to resurface..etc. If I chose...new valve guides and seats would bring it up to $250. My lifters, rockers, valves and Springs are A-ok.

They said they can hook me up with a another one if need be but my concern is that they may be used.

Not sure what Tony was recommending as far as repairing the head. From what I've read online cracks in cast aluminum heads are supposedly irreparable. GM even says to discard the entire head if found to be cracked.
 
Last edited:

Tonyrodz

Resident Resident
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Posts
31,469
Reaction score
46,641
Location
Central Jersey
The local engine shop said they will pressure test it for leaks. The charge would only be $25 if they find a leak. $150 if it's found to be ok. They would then continue to resurface..etc. If I chose...new valve guides and seats would bring it up to $250. My lifters, rockers, valves and Springs are A-ok.

They said they can hook me up with a another one if need be but my concern is that they may be used.

Not sure what Tony was recommending as far as repairing the head. From what I've read online cracks in cast aluminum heads are supposedly irreparable. GM even says to discard the entire head if found to be cracked.
I've never repaired a cracked head myself, I was just going under the assumption that a cracked aluminum head could be repaired. Depending on how bad the crack is, I don't see that it would be impossible--BUT--if it is cracked, I'd try to buy another head, if possible.
 
OP
OP
Matahoe

Matahoe

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2016
Posts
445
Reaction score
164
Location
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Definitely not impossible depending on the extent of the damage. A quick google search shows you drill and fill the crack with a screw. Supposedly it stops the progression of the crack.

Advance Auto has a refurbished head for about $230 after core return.
 
Last edited:

Tonyrodz

Resident Resident
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Posts
31,469
Reaction score
46,641
Location
Central Jersey
Definitely not impossible depending on the extent of the damage. A quick google search shows you drill and fill the crack with a screw. Supposedly it stops the progression of the crack.

Advance Auto has a refurbished head for about $230 after core return.
Is that a bare head?
 
Top