NBS vs OBS: Additional Info and test results
In a previous post I mentioned I replacing the OBS MC with the NBS MC from an 01 Silverado because of the success posted in this tread.
As I had mentioned the results where not great and though it could be an ABS computer issue. Here are the final findings and some hard numbers.
Using a GM Tech 2 tool I ran diagnostics and cycled the 4wABS unit. It passed without errors and had no codes set. After running the test the brakes were somewhat better but still not what I thought they should be. I again bled the brakes (2 person method) and cycled the ABS unit with no change. Obviously if I still had air in the line the pedal would not be rock hard.
I made some test passes then re-installed the obs MC and tested again.
Test findings:
1. The NBS MC provided a harder/stiffer pedal with less "mushy feel". This is misleading because even though the pedal travels less the actual braking amount is less when the same effort is applied.
Actual test 1 60 mph:
Standard one foot hard stop; braking using and equal amount of depression force with both MC's the Tahoe required an additional 12 feet extra space to come to a stop with the NBS, result: OBS stopped in less distance, no lockup or antilock activity was noted.
Actual test 2: 60 mph:
Panic stop, both feet; jamming both feet quickly on the pedal with high pressure the results are a little different, the NBS MC would lock up the brakes faster resulting in a 4 foot better stopping difference on the OBS MC. Antilock system was activated.
In both tests the OBS MC stop had much more pedal travel then the NBS MC.
Also, it appears there is less nose drive with NBS MC probably because the larger rear bore allows the rear brakes more fluid.
Based on those results one might say the NBS MC is better because you can get a lock up faster but I disagree, granted the NBS MC provides a nicer firmer pedal but what good is it when you have to push it so hard to get the equivalent stopping power.
Finally, the Wife test: Since my wife drives my Tahoe all the time I tried the following: I did not mention to her what I did, I pulled onto a back road and told her to drive, I told her I wanted to listen to something while she drove. I had her make a number of stops. Her first question was "is there something wrong with the brakes? She went on to say the pedal is really hard and it doesn't seem to stop as good as it used to. After I explained what I did her answer, "you ruined it, put it back the way it was".
Final conclusions:
At this point I am thinking of leaving the OBS MC in place and returning the NBS MC. I still cannot explain why the OBS MC appears to be a 40mm bore though I haven't pulled out the piston to verify the bore is actually that size. Perhaps someone has an answer for this.
Is the NBS MC the answer to a mushy pedal, In my opinion, no, true it will give you a hard pedal but what good is it if you really have to mash it on a hard stop. To me it somewhat degrades the driveability.
What would be the Possible solution? If you had a stronger Vacuum assist or Hydroboost unit giving you the extra force thus removing it from the driver that might be the ultimate answer. Both a non mushy brake that activates without a great amount of pedal force.
Bottom line and again my opinion, what constitues "good braking" is a matter of perspective. Some feel a rock hard pedal that locks up when you stand on it is better then a soft squishy pedal that only requires moderate effort with greater pedal travel. For men, maybe so, but for your wife, maybe not.
I am hoping SunlitComet can provide some input after he completes his hydroboot upgrade with NBS MC.
Constructive Comments Welcome!
Dan