Well well well... This doesn't look very good to me. Pulled the pan off, and yeah the oring has seen better days, it's pretty flat.
BUT, this isn't looking good to me. on the bottom of the pan there is a ton of sludge, with possibly a bunch of metal shavings mixed in. Moving it around my fingers it feels... well sludgy(lol) but also pretty gritty too.
I DO have a magnetic drain plug, could this overtime cause a build up of the metal shavings from regular use wear?
The story that I feel is being told here isn't a good one. First a tick starts. Then half of my oil pressure is gone, and then this sludgy mess on the bottom of the pan...
Here's some pictures and a video.
Video: