Thanks everyone for all your input. I decided to move forward with an 87/89 tune specifically because of the high fuel prices, now it seems like I won't be able to safely use 87 octane... frustrating. In any case, I'm almost at a half a tank and will add 91 since that is as high as I've seen in my area. I"ll come back with an update shortly... hopefully it's an easy fix.
Jenna, Hopefully you're right and I simply got some bad fuel. In the near future, I'll try going using some 87 octane from a reputable gas station and should the pinging continue I'll shoot you an email. Hopefully BB can take a look at my tune and see if it needs adjustment? I'm very happy with with my tune except for this issue.
What are your thoughts on octane boosters?