Urgent wheel replacement with junkyard rim and ended up replacing all four tires yesterday...
The Michelins came with the rims and were due for replacement by summer anyway.
I needed 1 wheel that fit to replace one that got damaged. A set identical to mine was on Craigslist nearby for $400, but they just sold the day before. They looked great too! I got one from the junkyard for $100. Not pretty, but fits and is at least same style.
I ended up with Cooper AT3 4S 265/70 R17. $220 each. Nice tire. Great tread, but good road manners on the highway. 3 Peaks rated for severe snow. Pretty quiet for AT tires.
Here is the crappy junkyard rim...
The other three were well cared for and looked great for their age. Maybe the ***** one will clean up good enough, so it looks good when you squint.
Anyone in MA/CT have this kind (from 2010-ish), in similar condition as my good ones, sitting in a garage, doing nothing for you, let me know. I might look to do something to get this ***** one off in a month or two.
I will just have to live with what I have for a little bit.