Growing up doesn't have to suck

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

OP
OP
iamdub

iamdub

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Posts
20,821
Reaction score
44,932
Location
Li'l Weezyana
Finished the 5K service yesterday.

Popped off both rocker covers to inspect. Not sure what's up with some of the rockers being darker. They're the originals and maybe they were on other cylinders. But, I swear I kept them all in their original positions. It appears to just be oil staining as it wiped off. :

IMG_8858.JPG


These are the 3/8" push rods. They were really close, but cleared when I tested them on the stand. Apparently, they still clear with the engine at 6,000 RPM. Minimizing flex is the point of fat rods, right? :

IMG_8864.JPG


I wanted to swap in sturdier rockers since I'm running the originals. Back in 2010ish, I had some ~20K-mile rockers fitted with a Comp trunnion upgrade kit. I never finished that build, sold the motor and those rockers sat on a shelf for 9+ years. A couple years ago, I put them in my brother's truck since his were damaged from loss of oil pressure. Not long after that, I stumbled across a bunch of old horror stories of how that Comp kit was failing- the trunnions were getting chewed up by the bearings, possibly from improper hardening. The issue seemed to be from around that time period. Playing it safe, I swapped 'em for some new OEM ones I had slated for mine. He only ran 'em for about 10K miles. Yesterday, I took a couple apart to inspect and saw what I believe is the beginning stages of the aforementioned failure.

The top/low-load side appears fine and you can see the band from where the needle bearings ride:

IMG_8860.JPG


The bottom/high load side is definitely worse. There was some pits (ignore the paper towel fibers) in the bottom centers that I could feel when I lightly drug a razor blade across them:

IMG_8859.JPG


I decided to not use them. I'll be getting something else, if not just another new OEM set.
 

Dantheman1540

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2020
Posts
4,856
Reaction score
10,502
Location
Sugar Loaf Mountain
Finished the 5K service yesterday.

Popped off both rocker covers to inspect. Not sure what's up with some of the rockers being darker. They're the originals and maybe they were on other cylinders. But, I swear I kept them all in their original positions. It appears to just be oil staining as it wiped off. :




These are the 3/8" push rods. They were really close, but cleared when I tested them on the stand. Apparently, they still clear with the engine at 6,000 RPM. Minimizing flex is the point of fat rods, right? :




I wanted to swap in sturdier rockers since I'm running the originals. Back in 2010ish, I had some ~20K-mile rockers fitted with a Comp trunnion upgrade kit. I never finished that build, sold the motor and those rockers sat on a shelf for 9+ years. A couple years ago, I put them in my brother's truck since his were damaged from loss of oil pressure. Not long after that, I stumbled across a bunch of old horror stories of how that Comp kit was failing- the trunnions were getting chewed up by the bearings, possibly from improper hardening. The issue seemed to be from around that time period. Playing it safe, I swapped 'em for some new OEM ones I had slated for mine. He only ran 'em for about 10K miles. Yesterday, I took a couple apart to inspect and saw what I believe is the beginning stages of the aforementioned failure.

The top/low-load side appears fine and you can see the band from where the needle bearings ride:




The bottom/high load side is definitely worse. There was some pits (ignore the paper towel fibers) in the bottom centers that I could feel when I lightly drug a razor blade across them:




I decided to not use them. I'll be getting something else, if not just another new OEM set.

I remember reading a few years ago about the Comp rocker downgrade failing people with mild cams, it's a good thing you caught that early! I have a set from CHE which is supposed to be "the best" but I will be inspecting them when I pull the heads this weekend.

Every set of OEM rockers I've seen one bank is always stained worse than the other so you may have gotten some mixed up. I looked into the different color causes and the general consensus was that it has to do with the PVC being on the driver side.
 

pwtr02ss

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Posts
11,750
Reaction score
25,195
Location
Tennessee
Finished the 5K service yesterday.

Popped off both rocker covers to inspect. Not sure what's up with some of the rockers being darker. They're the originals and maybe they were on other cylinders. But, I swear I kept them all in their original positions. It appears to just be oil staining as it wiped off. :

View attachment 362048


These are the 3/8" push rods. They were really close, but cleared when I tested them on the stand. Apparently, they still clear with the engine at 6,000 RPM. Minimizing flex is the point of fat rods, right? :

View attachment 362049


I wanted to swap in sturdier rockers since I'm running the originals. Back in 2010ish, I had some ~20K-mile rockers fitted with a Comp trunnion upgrade kit. I never finished that build, sold the motor and those rockers sat on a shelf for 9+ years. A couple years ago, I put them in my brother's truck since his were damaged from loss of oil pressure. Not long after that, I stumbled across a bunch of old horror stories of how that Comp kit was failing- the trunnions were getting chewed up by the bearings, possibly from improper hardening. The issue seemed to be from around that time period. Playing it safe, I swapped 'em for some new OEM ones I had slated for mine. He only ran 'em for about 10K miles. Yesterday, I took a couple apart to inspect and saw what I believe is the beginning stages of the aforementioned failure.

The top/low-load side appears fine and you can see the band from where the needle bearings ride:

View attachment 362050


The bottom/high load side is definitely worse. There was some pits (ignore the paper towel fibers) in the bottom centers that I could feel when I lightly drug a razor blade across them:

View attachment 362051


I decided to not use them. I'll be getting something else, if not just another new OEM set.
I have the BTR trunnion upgrade on mine. Not sure if they are good or POS. I just bought what my brother told me to.
 
OP
OP
iamdub

iamdub

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Posts
20,821
Reaction score
44,932
Location
Li'l Weezyana
I remember reading a few years ago about the Comp rocker downgrade failing people with mild cams, it's a good thing you caught that early! I have a set from CHE which is supposed to be "the best" but I will be inspecting them when I pull the heads this weekend.

Every set of OEM rockers I've seen one bank is always stained worse than the other so you may have gotten some mixed up. I looked into the different color causes and the general consensus was that it has to do with the PVC being on the driver side.

I don't even know what I was looking for when I stumbled upon that info when I did. They felt fine and I couldn't feel any slack, so I figured those failures were with high pressure springs on donkey díck cams turning 7,000 RPM. So I was gonna clean 'em up and roll with it. Glad I took some apart!

That makes sense about the rocker color. Two are darker, then two are light, then two more are dark, etc. I must've mixed 'em up.
 
OP
OP
iamdub

iamdub

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Posts
20,821
Reaction score
44,932
Location
Li'l Weezyana
I have the BTR trunnion upgrade on mine. Not sure if they are good or POS. I just bought what my brother told me to.

I'm actually looking at their offerings in another tab. If I can get genuine OEM rockers, I'd be fine with that. I'm running Z06 springs and only going to 6K. My cam has only a little more intake duration, same exhaust duration but .005" less lift than the Z06 cam. OEM rockers should be perfectly fine.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
132,245
Posts
1,864,681
Members
96,794
Latest member
Pippyochi
Top