Dave, thanks for the idea, I'll try it again and make sure that isn't the case. As a test, I used the old chain to see if it would go on and it went right on. However, there is some slack in that old chain considering it was on there for 306k.
If it turns out all links are seated, I think I'll go to my local GM dealership and buy just the chain and see if it works. If so, I'll just suck it up and pay the $75.00 additional for the GM chain and get over it...
If that doesn't work, then I'll probably resort to taking off the Cloyes crank sprocket and return everything and get a GM kit.
Kind of a PIA!